Solved the problem
Legal safety standards and regulations significantly improved
The tower is hundreds of years old and could easily have collapsed.
Once fixed the tower could be reopened as it’s a famous tourist attraction.
Accepting there were failures and making sure it never happens again
The Aberfan disaster was the collapse of a National Coal Board (NCB) spoil tip near the village of Aberfan on the morning of 21 October 1966. A spoil tip is a pile of waste rock and soil removed during coal mining.
Seeing the words 'Aberfan disaster' in this bicentenary collection of civil engineering projects may seem inappropriate. But it is the lessons learned from the disaster and the human errors in the months and years that preceded the tip failure that are explained here.
A fundamental principle for civil engineering to progress is the need to ensure that lessons are learned for future projects.
The first shaft for the Merthyr Vale Colliery was started in 1869 and the first coal produced in 1875. By 1916 the colliery had run out of space to tip the waste on the valley floor and began tipping on the mountainside above the village of Aberfan.
Tipping continued until 1966 by which time 7 tips had been constructed containing 2.7m cubic yards of colliery spoil.
Throughout this time there was a total absence of UK laws and regulations governing mine and quarry waste tips and spoil heaps and the NCB had no tipping policy that would have enforced the need for appropriate design and management of tips.
The steep hillside above Aberfan was riddled with springs and no effort was made to enclose the streams that would eventually be buried beneath the tips.
A large failure of Tip 4 in 1944 was not even a reportable incident because nobody from the colliery was injured – so many who should have heard about this or other similar events never did. The professionals in charge were inappropriately qualified and lacked appropriate experience and direction.
Concerns were raised that this represented a disaster waiting to happen but clear warnings went unheeded and no action was taken to address the situation. Until it was too late.
Tip 7 covered material which had previously slipped in 1944 – the very same watercourse that had caused earlier failures. Its catastrophic failure on 21 October 1966 was the result of a build-up of water in the tip.
When a small slip occurred the disturbance caused the saturated, fine material of the tip to liquefy and flow down the mountain.
140,000 cubic yards of black slurry avalanched down the mountainside wiping out everything in its path and continued down to the village. It destroyed a farmhouse, cottages, 18 houses, Pant Glas Junior and part of the neighbouring County Secondary School – before finally coming to rest.
At 9.20am the hooter at the colliery, which had never suffered a major disaster, broke its long silence. In total 144 lives were lost, 116 of them children. The loss comprised half the youth of Aberfan.
"What we can do… is try to focus the attention of many in Britain and beyond on the lessons of Aberfan, lessons which are still of profound relevance today. They touch on issues of public accountability, responsibility, competence and transparency.”HUW EDWARDS BBC Journalist, 50th Anniversary Of The Aberfan Disaster, 2016
Aberfan disaster - Lessons learned
In the 1960s an avalanche of tipped coal mixed with water slid down a hill in Aberfan and wiped out everything in its path. 144 people were killed. Many important engineering lessons have been learned in the wake of the tragedy.
Did you know …
There are other buildings that lean more than the tower of Pisa. The Capital Gate building in Abu Dhabi, UAE is the world's most tilted man-made tower. It has an 18 degree slope – 5 times more than Pisa – although it was deliberately constructed to slant.
How safety laws were changed after the disaster
In response to the the inquiry into the disaster at Aberfan significant advancements were made in the field of tip safety research and associated engineering and geological disciplines.
The Mines and Quarries (Tips) Act 1969 provided guidance for stable tips and the Mines and Quarries (Tips) Regulations 1971 gave detail on construction and inspection of tips.
This legislation stood the test of time with no amendments and no exemptions until both were replaced by the Mines Regulations 2014, which retains the provisions relating to tip stability.
The wider lessons learned from the disaster are fundamental to safe civil engineering of any kind. These include ensuring that:
- Suitable standards, codes of practice and legislation are in place and are reviewed and updated to ensure that schemes are planned, sustainable and designed for safety
- Regulation is suitably informed by targeted research
- Design, construction, management, inspection and regulatory professionals are always appropriately qualified and experienced
- Lessons are learned, captured, disseminated and fed back into future designs and also kept alive in the minds of the future generations of engineers
- We never forget the societal, community and health impacts of getting engineering so lamentably wrong.